# Indicates SCIAC Player of the Year
*Indicates SCIAC Newcomer of the Year
No counting games during 2020 season due to COVID-19.
| Year | First Team | Position | Second Team | Position |
| 2022 | Charlie Baum | Midfielder | Ciara Aw | Defender |
| Peyton Fendrich | Midfielder | |||
| 2021 | Eva Vlassopoulos | Forward | ||
| 2020 | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| 2019 | Emily Falla | Forward | Rilee Mezenen | Defender |
| Eva Vlassopoulos | Midfielder | |||
| Alexa Groesser | Forward | |||
| 2018 | Abby Nordquist | Defender | ||
| Hayley Romo | Midfielder | |||
| Eva Vlassopoulos | Forward | |||
| 2017 | Hannah Menk | Goalkeeper | ||
| Madison Mills | Forward/Defender | |||
| 2016 | Lauren Bay | Midfielder | ||
|
2015 |
Savannah Laursen# | Midfielder | Cassie Lively | Midfielder |
| Sam Keary | Defender | Faith Campbell | Defender | |
| Hannah Menk | Goalkeeper | |||
| 2014 | Sam Keary | Defender | Cassie Lively | Midfielder |
| Savannah Laursen | Midfielder | Amy Pumputis | Defender | |
| Lihini Weerasinghe | Forward | |||
| 2013 | Savannah Laursen | Midfielder | Sabrina Grandke-Bawab | Goalkeeper |
| Sam Keary | Defender | |||
| 2012 | Savannah Laursen* | Midfielder | Linzey Smith | Goalkeeper |
| Ellie Harrington | Defender | |||
| Kendall Pegan | Midfielder | |||
| 2011 | Fionna Connolly | Forward | Maddy Phillips | Midfielder |
| Kendall Pegan | Midfielder | Samantha Rivera | Forward | |
| Emily van den Bosch | Defender | |||
| 2010 | Fionna Connolly | Forward | Libby Sorg | Defender |
| Jessi Hoyt | Midfielder | Chelsea Hafley | Forward | |
| Sandie Shuker | Defender | |||
| 2009 | Maddy Phillips | Forward | Tenley Rawlings | Goalkeeper |
| Jessi Hoyt | Midfielder | Sandie Shuker | Defender | |
| Chelsea Hafley | Defender | Meghan King | Midfielder | |
| 2008 | Becky Willis# | Midfielder | Erica Jahn | Forward |
| Breann Puchalski | Defender | Tenley Rawlings | Goalkeeper | |
| Sandie Shuker | Defender | Libby Sorg | Defender | |
| 2007 | Kim Gerhardt | Defender | Kate Hanley | Defender |
| Becky Willis | Midfielder | Erica Jahn | Forward | |
| 2006 | Lindsey Fish# | Goalkeeper | Natalie Souders | Defender |
| Kate Hanley | Defender | Lauren Wiley | Midfielder | |
| Becky Willis | Midfielder | Erica Jahn | Forward | |
| Lauren Matta | Midfielder | |||
| 2005 | Lindsey Fish | Goalkeeper | Sarah Compton | Forward |
| Lisa Fryer | Forward | Katie McKee | Midfielder | |
| Kim Gerhardt | Defender | Heather Hodges | Defender | |
| 2004 | Ashley West# | Forward | Taylor Olson | Forward |
| Lauren Margetic | Forward | Jawny Sammons | Defender | |
| Heather Hodges | Midfielder | |||
| Katie McKee | Midfielder | |||
| Kim Gerhardt | Defender | |||
| 2003 | Ashley West | Forward | Lauren Margetic | Forward |
| Heather Hodges | Midfielder | Katie McKee | Midfielder | |
| Lisa Werner | Defender | Vicky Nigro | Midfielder | |
| 2002 | Sydney Johnson | Defender | Candace Hayward | Forward |
| Lauren Margetic | Forward | |||
| Sara Bonino | Midfielder | |||
| 2001 | Cristin Newkirk# | Defender | Madeline Hall | Forward |
| Lauren Margetic | Forward | Candace Hayward | Forward | |
| Geni Pascoe | Defender | Sydney Johnson | Midfielder | |
| Molly McDonald | Midfielder | |||
| 2000 | Lauren Spinelli | Forward | Candace Hayward | Forward |
| Jillian Aukland | Midfielder | Cristin Newkirk | Defender | |
| Sydney Johnson | Defender | |||
| 1999 | Kim Stafford | Goalkeeper | Bree Denison | Forward |
| Kendra Davis | Defender | Aurora Romans | Forward | |
| Jocelyn Chiary | Midfielder | |||
| Lauren Spinelli | Midfielder | |||
| 1998 | Bree Denison | Forward | Danielle Rocheleau | Forward |
| Amanda Ullyot | Defender | Molly McDonald | Midfielder | |
| Julia Cuder | Defender | |||
| 1997 | Aurora Romans | Forward | Shelby Olmstead | Midfielder |
| Molly McCollum | Midfielder | Gretchen Neff | Defender | |
| 1996 | none | Jen Longsdorf | Midfielder | |
| Eda Canales | Forward | |||
| 1995 | none | Shelby Olmstead | Midfielder | |
| Jen Longsdorf | Midfielder | |||
| 1994 | Molly McCollum | Defender | Jen Longsdorf | Forward |
| 1993 | none | none | ||
| 1992 | none | Allison Strack | ||
| 1991 | none | none | ||
| 1990 | Kelli Heisler | Holly Jung | ||
| 1989 | Marixa Mathews | none | ||
| Lynn Bassler | ||||
| Kelli Heisler | ||||
| 1988 | Marixa Mathews | none | ||
| 1987 | none | none | ||
| 1986 | Karen Schmitt | none | ||