All-SCIAC
| Year | First Team | Second Team |
| 2023 | Hannah Jugar% | |
| Kendall Nicholson | ||
| Andrea York | ||
| Iris Liu | ||
| 2022 | Hannah Jugar | Andrea York |
| Iris Liu | ||
| Kendall Nicholson | ||
| 2021 | Hannah Jugar+ | |
| Gabrielle Kiger* | ||
| Malia Kiger | ||
| Kendall Nicholson | ||
| 2020# | ||
| 2019 | Kendall Nicholson* + | Keilee Bessho |
| Annie Hay | ||
| 2018 | Caroline Ordian | Annie Hay |
| Elise Kiya | ||
| 2017 | Caroline Ordian + | |
| Kari Gordon | ||
| 2016 | Caroline Ordian+ | Kari Gordon |
| Amberlynn Dorsey | Raquel Gordon | |
| 2015 | Caroline Ordian*+ | Amberlynn Dorsey |
| Dalton Meade | Kari Gordon | |
| Raquel Gordon | ||
| 2014 | Raquel Gordon* | Dalton Meade |
| 2013 | Hannah Durette | Dalton Meade |
| 2012 | Hannah Durette | Hannah Purdy |
| Dalton Meade | Tracy Saracino | |
| Siarra Waddy | ||
Updated through 2023
First All-SCIAC selections in 2012
*SCIAC Newcomer of the Year
+SCIAC Player of the Year
%Character Award
#No awards due to season cancelation due to COVID-19