#indicates SCIAC Player of the Year
No 2020 season due to COVID-19.
| Year | First Team | Position | Second Team | Position | Character Award+ |
| 2022 | none | Alec Abrahamian | Defender | ||
| Ron Gvishi | Attacker | ||||
| 2021 | none | ||||
| 2019 | Spencer Allen | Attacker | Cooper Krause | Center | |
| 2018 | Grant Curry | Attacker | Spencer Allen | Attacker | Mitchell Walker |
| 2017 | Max Taylor | Utility | Mitchell Walker | ||
| 2016 | Danny Hartwig | Center-Defender | Max Taylor | Center-Defender | Kyle Murata |
| Chris Sekula | Goalkeeper | ||||
| 2015 | John Koning | Center | Mark Zikov | Center | Jake Funk |
| Chris Sekula | Goalkeeper | ||||
| 2014 | David Sekula | Center | Chris Sekula | Goalkeeper | David Sekula |
| Matthew Shippen | Center | ||||
| 2013 | Clint Freeman | Center | Quinn Curl | Driver | |
| Tyler Abbott | Goalkeeper | ||||
| 2012 | Clint Freeman | Driver | Michael Robinson | Driver | |
| 2011 | Blake vanHartesvelt | Center | Clint Freeman | Driver | |
| Jeff Parsons | Driver | ||||
| 2010 | Brendan Meaney | Center | Bo Sidhu | Driver | |
| Andrew Smith-Jones | Center-Defender | ||||
| 2009 | Ryan Floersch# | Center | Teddy Trowbridge | Goalkeeper | |
| Erik Grosshans | Driver | ||||
| John Floersch | 2m-Defense | ||||
| 2008 | Andrew Becskehazy# | Driver | Jim Kehrig | Utility | |
| Andrew Smith-Jones | 2m-Defense | ||||
| Brendan Meaney | Center | ||||
| 2007 | Ryan Hall | Center | Brendan Meaney | Center | |
| Andrew Becskehazy | Driver | ||||
| Tony Rona | Driver | ||||
| 2006 | Ryan Hall# | 2m-Offense | none | ||
| Andrew Becskehazy | Driver | ||||
| Ian Calpin | 2m-Offense | ||||
| 2005 | Casey Finfrock# | Goalkeeper | Tony Rona | Driver | |
| Ryan Hall | 2m-Defense | ||||
| Ian Calpin | 2m-Offense | ||||
| 2004 | Spencer Dinnean | Driver | Grant Culton | Driver | |
| Ryan Hall | 2m-Defense | Casey Finfrock | Goalkeeper | ||
| 2003 | Adam Foley# | 2m-Defense | none | ||
| Jay Boand | 2m-Offense | ||||
| Tyler Newgren | Goalkeeper | ||||
| Spencer Dinnean | Utility | ||||
| 2002 | Matt Ackley | 2m-Defense | Spencer Dinnean | 2m-Offense | |
| Adam Foley | Utility | James Graham | 2m-Defense | ||
| T.J. Harney | Driver | ||||
| 2001 | Kevin Rosa# | 2m-Offense | Spencer Dinnean | Utility | |
| T.J. Harney | Driver | Adam Foley | 2m-Defense | ||
| Scott Torosian | Driver | Tyler Newgren | Goalkeeper | ||
| 2000 | Kevin Rosa | 2m-Offense | Todd Black | Goalkeeper | |
| Bruce Tuttle | Utility | Tim McNaney | Utility | ||
| 1999 | Taj Jensen# | Tim McNaney | |||
| Matt Rosa | |||||
| Bruce Tuttle | |||||
| 1998 | Mike Dempsey | Matt Rosa | |||
| Taj Jensen | |||||
| 1997 | Taj Jensen | none | |||
| Andrew Smallman | |||||
| 1996 | none | Marcus Kahn | |||
| Christian Frid | |||||
| Taj Jensen | |||||
| Bob Paulhus | |||||
| 1995 | Greg Milton | Christian Frid | |||
| Sean McWhorter | Marcus Kahn | ||||
| Matt Carpenter | |||||
| 1994 | Sean McWhorter | none | |||
| Matt Carpenter | |||||
| 1993 | Greg Milton# | Marcus Kahn | |||
| Sean McWhorter | |||||
| Jared Young | |||||
| 1992 | Jared Young | Trevor Cox | |||
| Greg Milton | Sean McWhorter | ||||
| 1991 | Marcus Conklin | Jared Young | |||
| Scott Scherer | Jim Leonard | ||||
| 1990 | none | Scott Sherer | |||
| Pat Carpenter | |||||
| 1989 | Marcus Conklin | Mike Fidler | |||
| 1988 | Dave Langan | Greg Parker | |||
| 1987 | Dave Langan | ||||
| 1986 | none | ||||
| 1985 | Dave Boerlin | ||||
| 1984 | Dave Boerlin | ||||
| Jim Goyich | |||||
| 1983 | none | ||||
| 1982 | Jim Goyich | ||||
| Joe Schafer | |||||
| 1981 | none | ||||
| 1980 | none | ||||
| 1979 | Howard Fulton | ||||
| 1978 | none | ||||
| 1977 | none | ||||
| 1976 | Kevin Knight | ||||
| Lee Launer | |||||
| 1975 | Lee Launer | ||||
| 1974 | Lee Launer | ||||
| 1973 | Bill Wickett | Lee Launer | |||
| 1972 | Bill Wickett | Mike Perry | |||
| Walt Richardson | |||||
| Stan McNeill | |||||
| 1971 | Bill Deppe | Mike Perry | |||
| Kauka De Silva | |||||
| Ron Dandy | |||||
| Jay Thomas | |||||
| 1970 | Roger Patterson | Roy Newell | |||
| Phil Pattensen | |||||
| 1969 | Roger Patterson | Walt Welton | |||
| 1968 | Roger Patterson | Dick Berding | |||
| John Gorman | |||||
| Dan Thomas | |||||
| 1967 | Brook Sturtevant | Steve Morales | |||
| 1966 | John Ferman | Brook Sturtevant | |||
| Alan Newell | |||||
| 1965 | John Ferman | Brook Sturtevant | |||
| Alan Newell | |||||
| 1964 | John Ferman | ||||
| Keith Burnside | |||||
| 1963 | J. Burnside | J. Wiley | |||
| 1962 | Dick Johnson | ||||
| 1961 | Myron Tarkanian | Karl Phillips | |||
| Bill Bryant | |||||
| 1960 | Jim Gourley | ||||
| 1959 | none | ||||
| 1958 | none | ||||
In 2014, the SCIAC added an All-Sportsmanship Team, which included representatives from each institution. In 2018, that honor was changed to one recipient, based on leadership, athletic, and academic achivement.