| 2019-20 | Brad Cummins | D |
| Brysl Libao | D | |
| 2018-19 | Chase Lipscomb | S |
| Brad Cummins | D | |
| Brysl Libao | D | |
| 2017-18 | Chase Lipscomb | S |
| 2016-17 | Chase Lipscomb | S |
| 2015-16 | Jake Ly | D |
| Joey Dulle | D | |
| 2014-15 | Patrick Lipscomb | S, D |
| Nick Cummins | D | |
| 2013-14 | Patrick Lipscomb | S |
| 2012-13 | Patrick Lipscomb | S |
| 2011-12 | Patrick Lipscomb | D |
| Mark Bloom | D | |
| 2010-11 | Cameron Spearman | D |
| Jeff Casserd | D | |
| 2004-05 | Andrew Elling | D |
| Michael Thoeresz | S, D | |
| 2003-04 | Michael Thoeresz | S, D |
| Brian Murphy | S, D | |
| 2002-03 | Rob Condiotty | D |
| Brian Murphy | S, D | |
| 2001-02 | Brian Murphy | D |
| Rob Condiotty | S, D | |
| 2000-01 | Marco Bravo | D |
| Rob Condiotty | D | |
| Steve Marshburn | D | |
| Brian Murphy | D | |
| 1998-99 | Danilo Nepomuceno | S |
| 1995-96 | Steen Lundblad | D |
| Jeremy Munson | S, D | |
| Jason Oliver | S, D | |
| John Weston | D | |
| 1994-95 | Todd Born | S, D |
| John Weston | D | |
| 1993-94 | Todd Born | S, D |
| John Lansville | S | |
| 1992-93 | Mike Mell | D |
| Todd Born | S, D | |
| 1991-92 | Todd Born | S |
| 1989-90 | Sam Lizzul | D |
| Gordon Williams | D | |
| 1987-88 | John Flagg | S |
| 1986-87 | John Flagg | S, D |
| Jim Rowe | D | |
| 1985-86 | John Flagg | S |
| 1984-85 | Matt Armstrong | D |
| John Bunch | S, D | |
| Roy Chow | D | |
| Scott Moore | S, D | |
| 1983-84 | Roy Chow | D |
| Karl Behring | D | |
| Jeff Bubnack | D | |
| Kevin Gillette | S, D | |
| Scott Moore | S | |
| 1982-83 | Joe Alamo | S, D |
| Dan Langy | S, D | |
| Erik Michelsen | S, D | |
| Scott Moore | S, D | |
| Ken Turknette | D | |
| 1981-82 | Erik Michelsen | S |
| 1980-81 | Nelson Char | D |
| Bob Davis | S, D | |
| Ron Lusk | S, D | |
| Erik Michelsen | D | |
| 1979-80 | Mark Tappan | |
| Ron Lusk | ||
| Nelson Char | ||
| Ken Whitmer | ||
| 1978-79 | Ken Whitmer | |
| Mike Capelouto | ||
| Mark Tappan | ||
| 1977-78 | Joaquin Gonzalez | |
| Hadi Rahimi | ||
| Russell Miller | ||
| 1976-77 | Russell Miller | |
| 1975-76 | Kendall Char | |
| Hadi Rahimi | ||
| 1974-75 | Craig Edwards | |
| Jim Doal | ||
| Kendall Char | ||
| Dan Hanson | ||
| 1973-74 | Dan Hanson | |
| Mitch Finkelstein | ||
| Seabury Stanton | ||
| Dave Sallee | ||
| 1972-73 | John Brush | |
| Seabury Stanton | ||
| Mitch Finkelstein | ||
| 1971-72 | Randy Verdieck | |
| John Brush | ||
| Rich Tripp | ||
| 1970-71 | Randy Verdieck | |
| Dave Rasmussen | ||
| John Brush | ||
| Russel Greiner | ||
| Seabury Stanton | ||
| 1969-70 | Doug Verdieck | |
| Randy Verdieck | ||
| Paul Jamison | ||
| Steve Warfield | ||
| Dave Rasmussen | ||
| 1968-69 | Doug Verdieck | |
| Randy Verdieck | ||
| Paul Jamison | ||
| Steve Warfield | ||
| 1967-68 | Doug Verdieck | |
| Bruce Nelson | ||
| Alan Crute | ||
| 1966-67 | Doug Verdieck | |
| Steve Peacock | ||
| 1965-66 | John Yeomans | |
| Bill Schoen | ||
| 1964-65 | John Yeomans | |
| 1955-56 | Ray Simpson | |
| Deane Overmyer | ||
| 1953-54 | Ron Palmer | |
| Jerry Boas |
*Missing info for 1957-1964*
S = Singles, D = Doubles
Currently, a player must have met any of the following criteria to earn ITA All-America honors:
Singles
1.) Top 8 seed in NCAA singles tournament...or
2.) Win one round at NCAA singles tournament...or
3.) Finish in the Top 20 in the final ITA Rankings...or
4.) Win USTA/ITA Fall Regional Tournament...or
5.) Wins first-round match at the USTA/ITA National Small College Championships
(including players who receive at-large invitations to the tournament)
Doubles
1.) Top 4 seed in NCAA doubles tournament...or
2.) Win one round at NCAA doubles tournament...or
3.) Finish in the Top 10 in the final ITA Rankings...or
4.) Win USTA/ITA Fall Regional Tournament...or
5.) Wins first-round match at the USTA/ITA National Small College Championships
(including teams who receive at-large invitations to the tournament)