# indicates SCIAC Player of the Year
*indicates SCIAC Newcomer of the Year
No 2020 season due to COVID-19
| Year | First Team | Position | Second Team | Position |
| 2022 | Peyton Menti | Defender | Skylar Darwen | Defender |
| Ethan Kovach | Forward | Jarette Alexis Barajas | Midfielder | |
| Joseph Parra | Midfielder | |||
| 2021 | Arian Mogharei # | Midfielder | Peyton Menti | Defender |
| Mikey Flota | Defender | |||
| Steve Acuña | Midfielder | |||
| Collin ChubbFertal | Forward | |||
| Ethan Kovach | Forward | |||
| 2019 | Peyton Menti | Defender | Mikey Flota | Defender |
| Derrin Valeri | Midfielder | Collin ChubbFertal | Midfielder | |
| Steve Acuna | Forward | Joseph Parra | Midfielder | |
| Ethan Kovach | Forward | |||
| 2018 | Joey Kenney | Defender | Nick DeQuiroz | Defender |
| Arman Mogharei | Midfielder | Antony Chonga | Forward | |
| Kayvon Parsa | Forward | |||
| 2017 | Casey ChubbFertal # | Midfielder | Josh Haskill | Goalkeeper |
| Chase Boone | Forward | Antony Chonga | Forward | |
| Kayvon Parsa | Forward | Sergio Valencia | Midfielder | |
| Arman Mogharei | Midfielder | |||
| Ben Thompson | Defender | |||
| 2016 | Chase Boone | Forward | Kayvon Parsa | Forward |
| Casey ChubbFertal | Midfielder | |||
| Ben Thompson | Defender | |||
| Keoni Yates | Defender | |||
| 2015 | Kayvon Parsa* | Forward | Alexander Knox | Forward |
| Peter Marsden | Defender | Josh Haskill | Goalkeeper | |
| Tom Elsea | Defender | |||
| Casey ChubbFertal | Midfielder | |||
| Chase Boone | Forward | |||
| Keoni Yates | Defender | |||
| 2014 | Charles Izydorek# | Forward | ||
| Tom Elsea | Defender | |||
| Nico Johnson | Defender | |||
|
|
Matej Kustura | Forward | ||
|
2013 |
Richie Marquez # | Defender | Andreas Silva | Goalkeeper |
| Evan Keny-Guyer | Forward | Tom Elsea | Defender | |
| Charles Izydorek | Forward | |||
| Matej Kustura | Midfielder | |||
| 2012 | Gabe Ramirez | Midfielder | Evan Keny-Guyer | Defender |
| Richie Marquez | Defender | Matej Kustura | Midfielder | |
| Charles Izydorek | Forward | |||
| Andreas Silva | Goalkeeper | |||
| 2011 | Cody Carlson # | Forward | ||
| Jamie Griffin | Forward | |||
| Charles Izydorek* | Forward | |||
| Gabe Ramirez | Midfielder | |||
| Danny Day | Defender | |||
| Richie Marquez | Defender | |||
| Andreas Silva | Goalkeeper | |||
| 2010 | Cody Carlson | Forward | ||
| Jamie Griffin | Forward | |||
| Gabe Ramirez | Midfielder | |||
| Andreas Silva | Goalkeeper | |||
| Richie Marquez | Defender | |||
|
2009 |
Jeff Willey | Defender | Nick Gundersen | Midfielder |
| Cale Rodriguez | Midfielder | Andrew Lazarz | Defender | |
| Cody Carlson | Forward | |||
| 2008 | Ross Schunk# | Forward | Steve Chenes | Midfielder |
| Jeff Willey | Defender | Cale Rodriguez | Midfielder | |
| Alex Parker | Forward | |||
| Bryan Fakkema | Midfielder | |||
| 2007 | Bryan Fakkema # | Midfielder | none | |
| Kody Andrew | Midfielder | |||
| Max Bowman | Midfielder | |||
| Alex Parker | Forward | |||
| Ross Schunk | Forward | |||
| Jameson Martin | Defender | |||
| Andy Roraff | Goalkeeper | |||
| 2006 | Ross Schunk # | Forward | Max Bowman | Midfielder |
| Alex Parker | Forward | |||
| Jameson Martin | Defender | |||
| Bryan Fakkema | Midfielder | |||
| Silver Martinez | Defender | |||
| Andy Roraff | Goalkeeper | |||
| 2005 | Silver Martinez # | Defender | Brice Maloney | Defender |
| Kody Andrew | Forward | |||
| David Epstein | Defender | |||
| Bryan Fakkema | Midfielder | |||
| Chad Holash | Defender | |||
| Andy Roraff | Goalkeeper | |||
| Will Roraff | Forward | |||
| 2004 | Adam Acosta | Forward | Liam Connors | Midfielder |
| Jake Huber | Midfielder | Will Roraff | Forward | |
| Silver Martinez | Defender | |||
| Eric Rowling | Midfielder | |||
| 2003 | Adam Acosta # | Forward | David Epstein | Midfielder |
| Geoff Raives | Goalkeeper | K.C. Nordfors | Defender | |
| Sam Mirkovich | Forward | |||
| Jake Huber | Midfielder | |||
| Silver Martinez | Defender | |||
| Eric Rolwing | Midfielder | |||
| 2002 | Justin Wells # | Forward | Mike Hickman | Defender |
| Adam Acosta | Midfielder | Jake Huber | Midfielder | |
| Kestler Heitritter | Defender | Sam Mirkovich | Midfielder | |
| Geoff Raives | Goalkeeper | |||
| Eric Rolwing | Midfielder | |||
| 2001 | Andy Oshay # | Forward | Kestler Heitritter | Defender |
| Adam Acosta | Midfielder | Eric Rolwing | Midfielder | |
| Ryan Hoke | Defender | |||
| Aaron Nessman | Defender | |||
| Justin Wells | Forward | |||
| 2000 | Ryan Hoke | Midfielder | none | |
| Oliver King | Defender | |||
| Aaron Nessman | Defender | |||
| Andy Oshay | Midfielder | |||
| 1999 | Eric Kenas | Goalkeeper | Ryan Hoke | Midfielder |
| Andy Oshay | Forward | Riste Simnjanovski | Midfielder | |
| Aaron Nessman | Defender | Oliver King | Defender | |
| 1998 | Jon Bailey | Midfielder | Eric Kenas | Goalkeeper |
| Jason Braithwaite | Forward | |||
| Aaron Nessman | Defender | |||
| 1997 | none | Eric Kenas | Goalkeeper | |
| Jason Braithwaite | Forward | |||
| Jon Bailey | Midfielder | |||
| 1996 | Brian Fuller | Jon Bailey | ||
| Eric Kenas | Goalkeeper | |||
| Erik Tyndall | ||||
| 1995 | none | Greg Lackey | ||
| Brian Fuller | ||||
| 1994 | Miguel Agosto | Midfielder | Jon Gerken | Defender |
| Will Walker | Forward | Dashan Hayhurst | Midfielder | |
| 1993 | none | Chris Sellman | ||
| 1992 | Chris Sellman | Art Hogenauer | ||
| 1991 | Todd Sams | Goalkeeper | ||
| Chris Sellman | Midfielder | |||
| 1990 | none | Todd Sams | Goalkeeper | |
| Chris Sellman | Midfielder | |||
| Robbie Jordan | Defender | |||
| 1989 | Robbie Jordan | |||
| 1988 | none | Matt Copeland | ||
| Robbie Jordan | ||||
| 1987 | none | Todd Goodman | ||
| 1986 | none | Mike Hoyer | ||
| 1985 | Mike Hoyer | Dale Medearis | ||
| 1984 | Bill Collins | Dale Medearis | ||
| 1983 | Dale Medearis | |||
| 1982 | Lee Hedges | |||
| 1981 | Aine Rovell | |||
| Lee Hedges | ||||
| 1980 | none | |||
| 1979 | none | Slamak Kalhor | ||
| 1978 | none | John Paulachek | ||
| Jim Hung | ||||
| 1977 | none | none | ||
| 1976 | none | none | ||
| 1975 | none | Neal Bader | ||
| M. Farwell | ||||
| 1974 | M. Farwell | Neal Bader | ||
| Emilio Cabrera | D. Krupnik | |||
| 1973 | M. Farwell | |||
| Emilio Cabrera | ||||
| 1972 | Phillip Gottleib | Eric Pierpoint | ||
| Tom Beck | ||||
| 1971 | Glen Salter | Reiland | ||
| 1970 | none | Glen Salter | ||
| Emilio Cabrera | ||||
| Tom Beck | ||||
| 1969 | none | Gregg Terry | ||
| Peter Hsu | ||||
| Tom Beck | ||||
| 1968 | Peter Hsu | |||
| 1967 | Mumatz Tugtan | |||
| Rusty Weaver | ||||
| Mel Brooks | ||||
| Alex Thurman |