| Year | First Team | Position | Second Team | Position |
| 2022 | Evan Aguon | WR | Andrew Kellstrom | RB |
| Kaleb Gibson | OL | Jacob Sega | LB | |
| Mikey Duran IV | DL | Jadin Michaels | DB | |
| Craig Hunter | LB | Vicente Garcia | P | |
| Scott Tinsley | DB | |||
| 2021 | Nathan Martinez% | QB | Kai Kang | WR |
| Kai Thompson | RB | Cody Paul | OL | |
| Anthony Vargas | OL | Solomon Iosefa | DL | |
| Calhoun Helmberger | OL | Vicente Garcia | P | |
| Brandon Serrano | DL | |||
| Jacob Harrold | LB | |||
| Michael MacDonald | LB | |||
| Scott Tinsley | DB | |||
| 2019 | Nathan Martinez | QB | Calhoun Helmberger | OL |
| Mason Carvalho | RB | Brandon Serrano | DL | |
| Blake Roy | TE | Joe Bennett | LB | |
| Joey Caffaro | OL | |||
| Cody Paul | OL | |||
| Elias Hackney | DL | |||
| Matthew Betancourt | LB | |||
| Jeff Hector | DB | |||
| Vincent Vanhorne | DB | |||
| Alex Raya | K | |||
| Alex Raya | P | |||
| Khory Day | SPT | |||
| 2018 | Conner Kennedy | RB | David Molina | WR |
| Blake Roy | TE | Calhoun Helmberger | OL | |
| Tommy Garcia | OL | Elias Hackney | DL | |
| Joe Munroe | DL | Peter Riccolo | LB | |
| Nick Castro | LB | Marvin Perkins Jr. | DB | |
| Chad Virgil | DB | Alexander Raya | P | |
| Nathan Hierlihy | K | Elias Hackney | SPT | |
| 2017 | Tommy Garcia | OL | Levi Plante | QB |
| Joe Munroe | DL | Josiah Alvira | RB | |
| Mitch Shepherd | LB | Cole Blackburn | WR | |
| Daniel Gonzales | DB | Toma Suafoa-Aumavae | OL | |
| Nathan Hierlihy | K | Matthew Schallert | OL | |
| Tristan Corwin | DL | |||
| Curren Lapes | LB | |||
| Dustin Nascimento | DB | |||
| Nathan Hierlihy | P | |||
| Nathan Hierlihy | SPT | |||
| 2016 | Mitch Shepherd* | LB | Tommy Garcia | OL |
| Tristan Corwin | DL | Cole Blackburn | WR | |
| Connor Hoffman | DB | Dustin Nascimento | DB | |
| Matt Schallert | OL | |||
| 2015 | Matt Schallert | OL | Cole Blackburn | WR |
| Tristan Corwin | DL | Jack Rulon | DL | |
| Mitch Shepherd | LB | Justin Lantz | LB | |
| Colin Spencer | DB | Jalen DeVine | DB | |
| Sean Murray | K | Aaron Mandell | DB | |
| Sean Murray | P | Colin Spencer | SPT | |
| 2014 | Kevin Russell | QB | Bobby Brown | RB |
| Zachary Alford | OL | James Ramirez | WR | |
| Jordan Bixler | DL | Aaron Hinkle | OL | |
| Michael Tootle | LB | Mason Marino | OL | |
| Connor Hoffman | DB | Brian Keyser | DL | |
| Jack Rulon | DL | |||
| Mitch Shepherd | LB | |||
| Stephen Reyes | DB | |||
| Sean Murray | K | |||
| 2013 | Steven Locke Jr.* | DL | Aaron Atkins | WR |
| Kevin Russell | QB | Jorge Cervantes | OL | |
| Aaron Hinkle | OL | Nick Kido | DB | |
| Daniel Kane | DL | |||
| Sean Woods | DL | |||
| Michael Tootle | LB | |||
| Brandon Morris | DB | |||
| 2012 | Jordan Garcia* | LB | Daniel Kane | DL |
| Steven Locke Jr. | DL | Greyson Alman | LB | |
| Scott Payton | DB | Brandon Morris | DB | |
| Chad Hurst | QB | Brad Crisanty | RB | |
| Peter Kinney | OL | Taylor Irwin | WR | |
| Kevin Grady | K | Daryl Andersen | TE | |
| Dylan Wood | OL | |||
| 2011 | Sam Albrecht | OL | Peter Kinney | OL |
| Wes Norris | P | Chris Radtke | OL | |
| Brett Hutter | DL | Brad Crisanty | RB | |
| Randy Crim | DL | Chad Hurst | QB | |
| Jordan Garcia | LB | Tyler Aubrey | WR | |
| Josh Herrera | DB | Tony Santini | LB | |
| Kevin Grady | K | Vince Aiello | DB | |
| 2010 | Mike Nicolini* | DB | Brad Crisanty | RB |
| Taylor Irwin^ | WR | Evan Reuter | WR | |
| Chris Radtke | C | Rick Albrecht | OL | |
| Alex Ouji | DL | Wes Norris | P | |
| Jordan Garcia | LB | Brett Hutter | DL | |
| Josh Herrera | JR | Tony Santini | LB | |
| Rudy Vidales | DB | |||
| Vince Aiello | DB | |||
| Mike Nicolini | SPT - Ret | |||
| 2009 | Dan Selway | QB | Daylan Swedlow | RB |
| Brian Putman | WR | Rick Albrecht | OL | |
| Travis McBride | OL | Michael Nicolini | SPT - Ret | |
| Josh Cunningham# | DL | Josh Herrera | DB | |
| Ian Sluss | LB | |||
| Michael Nicolini | DB | |||
| 2008 | Zack Schafer | RB | Tom Romaine | RB |
| Mike Nicolini | PR | Nick Schroeder | TE | |
| Mike Nicolini | DB | Brenden Barkate | WR | |
| Brock Arndt | DL | Jared Schwass | OL | |
| Gavril Gabriel | DL | Travis McBride | OL | |
| Eddie Stamm | LB | Tyler Sutton | DL | |
| Ian Sluss | LB | |||
| Conor Drake | DB | |||
| Wes Norris | P | |||
| 2007 | Dan Selway% | QB | Tom Romaine | RB |
| Kyle Godfrey | WR | Mitch Crocco | DL | |
| Zach Schafer | RB | Eddie Stamm | LB | |
| Jake Lacey | TE | |||
| D.J. Tano | OL | |||
| Jared Schwass | OL | |||
| Kris Richardson | LB | |||
| Gavril Gabriel | DL | |||
| Brock Arndt | DL | |||
| Jerel Garcia | DB | |||
| Conor Drake | DB | |||
| 2006 | Mark Thorn | OL | Zach Schafer | RB |
| Tyson McGuire | TE | Russell DeMent | OL | |
| Brock Arndt | DL | Kris Richardson | LB | |
| Keith Richardson | LB | Kyle Godfrey | WR | |
| Brad Smith | DB | Gavril Gabriel | DL | |
| 2005 | Mark Thorn | OL | Alex Ballard | WR |
| Karl Mikolon | RB | Corey White | DL | |
| Gary La Russa | LB | Nick Steele | LB | |
| Brad Smith | DB | |||
| 2004 | Steve Markus | OL | Drew Lewis | OL |
| Charles Coleman | WR | Nick Steele | LB | |
| Les Simon | RB | Marcus Guzman | DB | |
| Noel Lopez | DL | Stuart Pohl | P | |
| Troy Sellers | LB | |||
| 2003 | Steve Markus | OL | Chris Niswonger | OL |
| Brian Sapp | QB | Justin Wilcox | WR | |
| Les Simon | RB | Jacob Smeltzer | TE | |
| Mike Werner | DL | Jarod Hamman | DL | |
| Esteban Valenzuela | DB | Chris Mankin | LB | |
| Kyle Beach | K | |||
| 2002 | Jeff Thomas* | DB | Steve Markus | OL |
| Trent Anderson | OL | Jeff Kadau | TE | |
| Clay Groefsema | QB | Jake Helveston | DL | |
| Tony Skulick | WR | Aaron Shires | DL | |
| Les Simon | RB | Scott Murtishaw | LB | |
| Danny Jocson | LB | Marcus Tromp | DB | |
| Josh Bullock | DB | Sean Lipscomb | K | |
| 2001 | John Dixon | WR | Ryan Keyes | OL |
| Shawn Watson | RB | John Opp | OL | |
| Justin Lowell | DL | Clay Groefsema | QB | |
| Phil Pinegar | LB | Shawn Kelly | TE | |
| Ben Ballard | DB | Jake Helveston | DL | |
| Wade Smith | DB | Aaron Shires | DL | |
| Jeff Thomas | DB | |||
| Sean Lipscomb | P | |||
| 2000 | Brandon Ford% | RB | Chris Dunn | OL |
| Clint Treadway | OL | Jake Resch | OL | |
| Sean Whipkey | OL | Sean Kelly | TE | |
| Chad Hustead | WR | Kris Jower | DL | |
| David Seale | DL | Ryan Valentine | LB | |
| Javier Garcia | LB | |||
| Ben Ballard | DB | |||
| Wade Smith | DB | |||
| Sean Lipscomb | K/P | |||
| 1999 | Danny Ragsdale% | QB | Chris Dunn | OL |
| Clint Treadway | OL | Steve Sutherland | DL | |
| Chad Hustead | WR | Sean Lipscomb | K/P | |
| Jeff Wray | WR | |||
| Melvin White | TE | |||
| Scott Foster | DL | |||
| Ryan Valentine | LB | |||
| Wade Smith | DB | |||
| 1998 | Rob Benson* | Efren Graban | OL | |
| Danny Ragsdale# | QB | Scott Foster | DL | |
| Kenny Welton | OL | Jeff Wray | WR | |
| Israel Arciniega | OL | Matt Merlo | DB | |
| Bobby Bruce | WR | |||
| Dempsey Holder | DL | |||
| Corey Foster | LB | |||
| Tim Sikorski | DB | |||
| Rob Demichiel | K | |||
| 1997 | Israel Arciniega | OL | Chris Martinez | OL |
| Sergio Gomez | OL | Danny Ragsdale | WR | |
| Brian Hayes | TE | Dempsey Holder | DL | |
| Marty Rincon | QB | Tom Shults | LB | |
| Trent Bordok | DL | James Pazak | DB | |
| Tim Sikorski | DB | |||
| 1996 | Jose Marquez | OL | Sergio Gomez | OL |
| Damian Delfino | WR | Eric Pearson | OL | |
| Rino Marconi | QB | Mike Benson | WR | |
| Trent Bordok | DL | Ralph Martinez | WR | |
| Buddy Wellman | K | Brian Hayes | TE | |
| Bert Coutts | DL | James Evans | LB | |
| Kendrick McDaniel | DL | Hung Nguy | LB | |
| Mike Goldstein | LB | Tim Sikorski | DB | |
| Morgan Bannister | DB | Tye Gloria | P | |
| 1995 | Matt Figueroa | Patrick McDonald | ||
| Chris Calnon | Alaric Greenfield | |||
| Brian Hayes | TE | Danny Green | ||
| James Evans | LB | Buddy Wellman | ||
| Morgan Bannister | DB | Mike Goldstein | LB | |
| Richy Cummings | ||||
| 1994 | Matt Figueroa | Chris Calnon | ||
| Gary Giannoni | DB | Rob Fassler | ||
| Joe Kelly | Alaric Greenfield | |||
| Tomek Mikler | P | Anthony Jones | RB | |
| Andy Sulick | Roc Roggeveen | OL | ||
| Jesse Theodore | ||||
| Mike Weiland | DL | |||
| Brett Wixom | LB | |||
| 1993 | Rob Roggeveen | OL | Anthony Jones | RB |
| Mike Weiland | DL | Rob Abinet | DL | |
| Kelly Cooper | LB | Mike Munoz | DL | |
| Demond White | LB | Tomek Mikler | P | |
| Gary Giannoni | DB | Scott Hartman | L | |
| Jesse Theodore | L | |||
| 1992 | Scott Hartman | OL | Matt Schulenberg | TE |
| Rob Roggeveen | OL | Rod Abinet | DL | |
| Jesse Theodore | OL | Demond White | LB | |
| Kurt Bruich | WR | Brett Wixom | LB | |
| Sean Cheatham | RB | Gary Giannoni | DB | |
| Garrett Skipper | K | Kris Vercauteren | DB | |
| James Shields | DL | |||
| Mike Weiland | DL | |||
| Brian Baldwin | LB | |||
| Hans Haglund | LB | |||
| Kris Vercauteren | P | |||
| 1991 | Curt Landreth | RB | Mike Caponetto | OL |
| Shaun Trejo | RB | Sean Cheatham | TE | |
| Tim Brown | OL | Scott Catlin | DB | |
| Kurt Bruich | WR | Guy Nelson | DB | |
| Brian Harmon | QB | Demond White | LB | |
| Paul Querro | OL | |||
| Brian Baldwin | LB | |||
| James Mason | DB | |||
| Mike Opp | DE | |||
| James Shields | OL | |||
| Steve Stokes | LB | |||
| Brett Wixom | LB | |||
| 1990 | Carl Schroeder | TE | Robert Kirkland | OL |
| Tim Brown | OL | James Bradney | RB | |
| Mike Caspino | OL | Shaun Trejo | RB | |
| Paul Querro | OL | Bob Olshan | DL | |
| Brian Harmon | QB | Kris Vercauteren | P | |
| Curt Landreth% | RB | |||
| Kurt Bruich | WR | |||
| Keith Gissel | DL | |||
| Michael Opp | DL | |||
| Hans Haglund | LB | |||
| Bryan Mills | LB | |||
| John Thompson* | LB | |||
| Dennis Kroll | DB | |||
| James Mason | DB | |||
| 1989 | Curt Landreth | RB | Kris Vercauteren | P |
| Robert Lagsdin | OL | Tim Brown | OL | |
| Doug Bos | LB | Keith Gissel | DL | |
| Dennis Kroll | DB | Carl Schroeder | TE | |
| Tony Gray | DL | John Thompson | LB | |
| 1988 | Rob Lagsdin | Chris Garcia | ||
| Ruffin Patterson | Carl Schroeder | |||
| Eric Carlson | Tom Bain | |||
| Bart Groninger | John Thompson | |||
| Doug Bos | ||||
| Rick Bennett | ||||
| 1987 | Rick Bennett | Mike Sanders | ||
| Paul San Fillippo | Mark Mickelson | |||
| 1986 | Eric Carlson | Tom Gianelli | ||
| Mike Bodine | ||||
| Paul San Fillippo | ||||
| Ricky Perez | ||||
| Richard Bennett | ||||
| 1985 | Tom Gianelli | Nick Maniatis | ||
| Neal Pahia | Jeff Stricherz | |||
| Ed Soto | Mark Mickelson | |||
| Ricky Perez | ||||
| 1984 | Neal Pahia | Greg Hersey | ||
| Scott Napier | Tim Koshmerl | |||
| Jeff Heidrick | Jeff Stricherz | |||
| 1983 | Steve Beck | Mike Acevedo | ||
| Glenn Gaines | Steve Hess | |||
| Peter Helfrich | Martin Hubbard | |||
| Mike Remsen | ||||
| 1982 | John Fryday | Marcus Earle | ||
| Nate Upshaw | Rick Swanson | |||
| Steve Hess | Martin Hubbard | |||
| Peter Helfrich | Andy Anderson | |||
| Jeff Jones | ||||
| 1981 | Alan Byron | Peter Strong | ||
| Tony Haertl | Craig Winninghoff | |||
| Brad Austin | Gary Downs | |||
| Doug Dodson | Steve Miliate | |||
| Nate Upshaw | ||||
| Mike DePeel | ||||
| Steve Hess | ||||
| Jeff Jones | ||||
| 1980 | Kelly Thomas | David Sevey | ||
| Alan Byron | Russell Winninghoff | |||
| Tony Haertl | John Fouch | |||
| Brad Austin | Don Fleming | |||
| Mike Remy | Nate Upshaw | |||
| Nick DeMarco | Doug Dodson | |||
| Sam Richey | ||||
| Kent Kraning | ||||
| Paul Price | ||||
| 1979 | Tony Haertl | David Sevey | ||
| Sam Richey | Mike Aloia | |||
| Paul James | Don Fleming | |||
| Randy Blalock | Mike Remy | |||
| Rich Rebenstorf | ||||
| 1978 | David Simmons | Don Fleming | ||
| Kelly Thomas | Rob Sibley | |||
| Jeff Green | Rick Butler | |||
| Tom Basacas | ||||
| Jim Conley | ||||
| Tony Haertl | ||||
| Brad Steward | ||||
| Steve James | ||||
| Ed McLaren | ||||
| Randy Blalock | ||||
| 1977 | Brian DeRoo | Scott Thomas | ||
| Roy Chien | Paul Jessup | |||
| Randy Van Horn | ||||
| Chris Brumfield | ||||
| David D'Arcangelo | ||||
| Greg Harper | ||||
| Skip Buck | ||||
| Bruce White | ||||
| 1976 | Brian DeRoo | Scott Thomas | ||
| Randy Van Horn | Paul Jessup | |||
| Scott Thomas | ||||
| Steve Vento | ||||
| David D'Arcangelo | ||||
| Skip Buck | ||||
| Rich Godinez | ||||
| Bob Ollar | ||||
| 1975 | Randy Van Horn | Bob Downs | ||
| Chris Van Zee | David D'Arcangelo | |||
| Brian DeRoo | Bruce Christensen | |||
| Steve Vento | Lee Joyce | |||
| Kelly Yank | ||||
| Floyd Braggs | ||||
| Don Bradovich | ||||
| Bob Ollar | ||||
| 1974 | Eric Thomason | David D'Arcangelo | ||
| Ed Killian | Floyd Braggs | |||
| Tom Strzykalski | Randy Evans | |||
| Chris Van Zee | ||||
| Chuck Hiroto | ||||
| Jim North | ||||
| Alex Boyd | ||||
| Butch Edge | ||||
| Paul Joyce | ||||
| 1973 | Eric Thomason | Don Shelbourne | ||
| Tom McCutchen | Rich McGowan | |||
| Steve Blalock | Butch Edge | |||
| Tim Streeter | John Simmons | |||
| Jerry Zigrossi | ||||
| Don Alvarez | ||||
| 1972 | Tim Streeter | Don Alvarez | ||
| Tom McCutchen | Rich McGowan | |||
| John Magner | Butch Edge | |||
| Clayton Record | ||||
| Henry Washington | ||||
| 1971 | Bob Bell | John Magner | ||
| Jack Cosby | Tim Streeter | |||
| Randy Verdieck | Steve Roy | |||
| 1970 | Hank Cochrane | Bob Bell | ||
| Greg Murray | Gary Brown | |||
| Jack Cosby | John Coleman | |||
| Frank Grossman | Jim Porterfield | |||
| Randy Verdieck | Rob Selway | |||
| David Crist | ||||
| John Stary | ||||
| 1969 | John Coleman | Bill McAllister | ||
| Hank Cochrane | Dan Brown | |||
| Rick Dischinger | Jim Porterfield | |||
| Tom Hoak | David Crist | |||
| Frank Grossman | ||||
| Dan Higson | ||||
| Randy Verdieck | ||||
| 1968 | Chuck Baker | Hank Cochrane | ||
| Rick Dischinger | Charles Garrett | |||
| Ted Hedgpeth | Art Darin | |||
| Frank Grossman | Gary Ovitt | |||
| Dan Higson | ||||
| Charles Chiappone | ||||
| 1967 | Don Ford | Charles Baker | ||
| John Hoak | Dick Holmes | |||
| Charles Chiappone | Rich Dischinger | |||
| John Romo | ||||
| Ted Hedgpeth | ||||
| Ron Grout | ||||
| 1966@ | Ralph Milhiser | Bill Hoover | ||
| John Hoak | Tom Rees | |||
| Gary Krueger | Dennis Minder | |||
| John Romo | Ted Hedgpeth | |||
| Larry Nelson | Chuck Milhiser | |||
| Don Ford | Charles Chiappone | |||
| 1965 | Don Ford | |||
| Ray Vincent | ||||
| Bob Campbell | ||||
| Larry Nelson | ||||
| 1964 | Bob Jones | |||
| Bill Snyder | ||||
| Bob Campbell | ||||
| Harvey Pinyoun | ||||
| 1963 | Dennis Casino | |||
| Jim Brondino | ||||
| Bob Jones | ||||
| Chuck Petterson | ||||
| Paul Riggins | ||||
| 1962 | Phil Brown | |||
| Jim Brondino | ||||
| Joe Cortez | ||||
| 1961& | Myron Tarkanian | Karl Phillips | ||
| Marshall Nixon | Bill Bryant | |||
| Rollin Grider | ||||
| Roger Chaney | ||||
| 1960 | Marshall Nixon | Doug Mattox | ||
| Rollin Grider | Philip Brown | |||
| Roger Chaney | ||||
| Leo Guest | ||||
| 1959 | Doug Mattox | Jim Taylor | ||
| Claude Sharpe | Jerry Neuman | |||
| Norm Yetman | ||||
| Tim Burroughs | ||||
| Roger Chaney | ||||
| 1958 | Bob Peavy | Merv Lovenburg | ||
| Claude Sharpe | ||||
| Jim Frye | ||||
| Tim Burroughs | ||||
| 1957 | Claude Sharpe | Bob Peavy | ||
| Norm Smothers | ||||
| Howard Tipton | ||||
| 1956 | Jack Crowder | Joe Houser | ||
| Dean Westgaard | Mike Lewis | |||
| Howard Tipton | Howard Newman | |||
| 1955 | Howard Newman | Joe Houser | ||
| Ed Wohr | ||||
| 1954 | Paul Womack | Bruce Lamb | ||
| Scott Fowler | ||||
| 1953 | John Rushing | none | ||
| Jim Ellis | ||||
| 1952 | Jim Ellis | Rudy Valadez | ||
| Lowell Trask | ||||
| 1951 | none | John Horn | ||
| George Amrosek | ||||
| 1950 | Dan Moon | John Horn | ||
| Gregory Welton | Gregory Welton | |||
| Chuck Luciano | ||||
| 1949 | Robert Mockler | George Weaver | ||
| William Steward | ||||
| 1948 | Chuck Hackelman | none | ||
| 1947 | Stan Flowers | Homer Richards | ||
| Ted Runner | Mack Hammond | |||
| Chuck Hackelman | ||||
| 1946 | Homer Richards | Stan Flowers | ||
| Keith Broaders | Pete Masonis | |||
| John Hoffman | Mack Hammond | |||
| Jim Lloyd | Ted Duncan | |||
| Ted Runner | ||||
| 1945 | War year- no conference selections | |||
| 1944 | War year- no conference selections | |||
| 1943 | War year- no conference selections | |||
| 1942 | E. Campbell | A. Fountain | ||
| T. Ellerman | ||||
| H. Wilkins | ||||
| F. Gallup | ||||
| 1941 | Robert Campbell | Gene Burson | ||
| Alvin Chang | Percy Burrows | |||
| Ted McKinney | ||||
| 1940 | Robert Campbell | James Eacutt | ||
| Bill Burrows | John Hoffman | |||
| Herb Morrelli | ||||
| Alvin Chang | ||||
| 1939 | none | Herb Morrelli | ||
| Roy Hill | ||||
| Jack Montgomery | ||||
| 1938 | Dick Pazder | none | ||
| 1937 | Mal Rink | Garth Huffaker | ||
| James Blaisdell | ||||
| 1936 | James Blaisdell | none | ||
| 1935 | Archie Cochran | Don Smith | ||
| Reinold Peterson | ||||
| William Spriggs | ||||
| James Blaisdell | ||||
| 1934 | Clarence Hunt | Don Kitch | ||
| Reinold Peterson | William Spriggs | |||
| Walter Johnson | Don Smith | |||
| Earl Bandy | ||||
| 1933 | Alden Simpson | Walter Gage | ||
| Earl Bandy | Don Baum | |||
| Dale Perkins | Archie Cochran | |||
| 1932 | Delcarlo | Speth | ||
| Hales | Perkins | |||
| MacKenzie | ||||
* Indicates Defensive Player of the Year honor
% Indicates Offensive Player of the Year honor
^ Indicates Rookie of the Year
# John Zinda Award
@ First year that the SCIAC included second teams for both offense and defense
& Final year for first and second teams for both offense and defense combined
No 2020 season due to COVID-19