SCIAC Rookies of the Year (listed separately)
*Indicates SCIAC Player of the Year
#Indicates SCIAC Pitcher of the Year
%Indicates SCIAC Newcomer of the Year
| Year | First Team | Position | Second Team | Position | Coaching Staff of the Year | Sportsmanship Award |
| 2022 | Collette Allen* | SS | Kalyn Kershner | UTL | Yes | |
| Tyesen Gordon | 1B | Paige Messenlehner | UTL | |||
| Danielle Stallings | P | |||||
| 2021 | Collette Allen*% | UTL | Yes | |||
| Danielle Stallings# | P/OF | |||||
| Madison Alves | INF | |||||
| Rylie Barber | C | |||||
| Tsianina Flores | OF | |||||
| Natalie Horton | INF | |||||
| 2020 | ||||||
| 2019 | Julianne Rodriguez | 2B | Nova Siegel | C | ||
| 2018 | Shannon Skrzynski | UTL | Olivia Vierra | 1B | Jordyn Smith | |
| Samantha Rivas | CF | |||||
| 2017 | Lali Garza | C | Amanda Ang | CF | Ursyla Baumgarten | |
| 2016 | Vicki King | 2B | Grace Rose | OF | Summer Smith | |
| AJ Carrasco | OF | Lauren Henson | P | |||
| Dani Santos | C | |||||
| 2015 | Amanda Lievanos | RF | Shannon Skrzynski | SS | Aisha Salami | |
| AJ Carrasco | OF | Vicki King | 1B | |||
| 2014 | Kaitlyn Hooper | P | Kristen Hooper | UT | ||
| Amanda Clark | 2B | |||||
| Amanda Lievanos | CF | |||||
| AJ Carrasco | OF | |||||
| Vicki King | SS | |||||
| 2013 | Kayla Uphold* | P | AJ Carrasco | OF | ||
| Sarah Beeman | OF | |||||
| Nikoli Sharp | DP | |||||
| 2012 | Kayla Uphold* | P | Linda Park | SS | ||
| Rikki Scates | 1B | |||||
| Amanda Lievanos | OF | |||||
| Amanda Clark | UT | |||||
| Breanna Ruelas | P | |||||
| 2011 | *Amanda Lievanos | OF | Molly Duran | 2B | ||
| Kayla Uphold | P | Janelle Carrasco | OF | |||
| Lizett Casillas | 1B | Amanda Clark | SS (At-Large) | |||
| Aleisha Martinez | 3B | |||||
| 2010 | Olivia Ellis | P | ||||
| Breanna Ruelas | UT | |||||
| Nicky Neumann | C | |||||
| Kayla Peterson | OF | |||||
| Amanda Doeppel | DP | |||||
| Lizett Casillas | 1B | |||||
| Lindsay Henry | 3B | |||||
| 2009 | Olivia Ellis | P | Lizett Casillas | 1B | ||
| Dory Baga | 2B | |||||
| Kayla Peterson | OF | |||||
| Amanda Doeppel | DP | |||||
| Nicky Neumann | C (At-Large) | |||||
| 2008 | Dory Baga | 2B | Melanie Hamlin | SS | ||
| Katie Brnca | P | Olivia Ellis | P | |||
| Amanda Doeppel | DP | |||||
| *Nicky Neumann | C | |||||
| Remy Kawaguchi | OF | |||||
| 2007 | Katie Brnca | P | Olivia Ellis | P | ||
| *Allyson Leslie | CF | |||||
| Arlene Martinez | 2B | |||||
| Ashley Serbus | C | |||||
| Kolbi Sprague | SS | |||||
| 2006 | Allyson Leslie | CF | Melanie Hamlin | 2B | ||
| Katie Brnca | P | Roxy Lambert | DP | |||
| Ashley Serbus | C | |||||
| Lindsay Sutton | P | |||||
| 2005 | Megan Cooley | OF | Katie Brnca | P | ||
| Deborah Greer | DP | Courtney Cho | 2B | |||
| Allyson Leslie | OF | Lisa Curry | OF | |||
| Ann Marie Lozano | 1B | Melanie Hamlin | SS | |||
| Maritza Padilla | C | |||||
| Lindsay Sutton | P | |||||
| 2004 | Lindsay Sutton | P | Megan Cooley | DP | ||
| Maritza Padilla | C | Shelly Joshin | UT | |||
| 2003 | Renee Charpentier | OF | Amy Burton | 1B | ||
| Heather Johnson | OF | Maritza Padilla | C | |||
| Lindsay Sutton | P | Darcie Takemoto | UT | |||
| Jennifer Townsend | 3B | |||||
| 2002 | none | Courtney Cho | 2B | |||
| Allison Roeser | DP | |||||
| 2001 | Alaina Brubaker | CF | Marissa Card | 3B | ||
| Sara Burton | SS | Renee Charpentier | RF | |||
| Nicole Rinetti | P | Jennifer Overbeck | P | |||
| 2000 | Alaina Brubaker | OF | Catherine Waldron | 3B | ||
| Nicole Rinetti | P | Sara Foulkes | 1B | |||
| Manda Wood | C | |||||
| 1999 | Laura Egger | P | none | |||
| Sara Burton | 2B | |||||
| Alaina Brubaker | OF | |||||
| 1998 | Alaina Brubaker | OF | Heather Burns | P | ||
| 1997 | Ariana Bates | Christina De Leon | ||||
| Jen Martin | ||||||
| 1996 | Shawna Sherburne | OF | Tracy Grahn | SS | ||
| Heather Burns | P | |||||
| 1995 | Michelle Phillips | IF | Jennifer Martin | P | ||
| Tracy Grahn | IF | |||||
| 1994 | Michelle Phillips | IF | none | |||
| Tracy Grahn | OF | |||||
| Christy Colton | P | |||||
| 1993 | Christy Colton | P | Jennifer Riley | IF | ||
| Tracy Grahn | IF | |||||
| Michelle Phillips | OF | |||||
| Kim Locke | UT | |||||
| 1992 | Christy Colton | P | Kim Locke | C | ||
| Michelle Phillips | P | Jennifer Riley | IF | |||
| Shani Uggens | IF | Jennifer D'Anna | OF | |||
| Jennifer Boyette | OF | |||||
| 1991 | Christy Colton | Rachelle Englert | ||||
| Kim Locke | ||||||
| Tina Peterson | ||||||
| 1990 | *Chela Castano | Tina Peterson | ||||
| Michelle Leitzman | Christi Thompson | |||||
| Kim Locke | ||||||
| 1989 | Chela Castano | Kelli Heisler | ||||
| Janice Hall | Setsu Kuroda | |||||
| Tina Peterson | Cristi Thompson | |||||
| 1988 | Chela Castano | Jennifer Boyett | ||||
| Tina Peterson | Tish Hvall | |||||
| Mitzi Leitzman | Christi Thompson | |||||
| Simone Brard | ||||||
| Michelle Leitzman | ||||||
| 1987 | Chela Castano | Janice Hall | ||||
| Edy Davis | Lesley Laraway | |||||
| Stacey Freeman | Maura Varni | |||||
| Mitzi Leitzman |
Updated through the 2022 season
+ No All-SCIAC due to COVID-19 season cancelation
*Indicates SCIAC Player of the Year
Note- From 1983-86, softball competed in the SCSC.