| Year | First Team | Pos. | Second Team | Pos. | Sportsmanship Award | Name | Pos. | ||
| 2023 | Emma Beaver | MID | |||||||
| Emily Webster | ATT | ||||||||
| 2022 | Celine Flaig | ATT | Kaitlyn Lesko | DEF | Erika Lopez | ATT | |||
| Sydney Louie | MID | ||||||||
| 2021+ | Celine Flaig | ATT | |||||||
| Casey Lynch | DEF | ||||||||
| Maeve Wiencek | MID | ||||||||
| 2020* | |||||||||
| 2019 | Hanna Morford | MID | Sadie Pickering | ATT | |||||
| Kelsey Ruhl | ATT | ||||||||
| Alexis Pound | DEF | ||||||||
| 2018 | Lacey Bjorndal | MID | Quinn Egan | GK | Katie Koehler | DEF | |||
| Hanna Morford | MID | Kelsey Ruhl | ATT | ||||||
| Chelsea Sahami | DEF | ||||||||
| 2017 | Hanna Morford | MID | Dulce Moll | ATT | Katie Koehler | DEF | |||
| Quinn Egan | GK | Lacey Bjorndal | MID | ||||||
| Sadie Pickering | MID | ||||||||
| 2016 | Dulce Moll | ATT | Sam Keary | DEF | Angelyn Brown | DEF | |||
| Stephanie Garrett | MID | ||||||||
| 2015 | Stephanie Garrett-OPOY | Mid | Lacy Bjorndal | Mid | McKenna Tychsen | Attack | |||
| Sam Keary | Def | Emily Dalrymple | Mid | ||||||
| Dulce Moll | Attack | ||||||||
| 2014 | Stephanie Garrett - POY | Mid | Breanne Rideout | M | |||||
| Allie Hoffler | Attack | ||||||||
| KK McCaslin | Attack | ||||||||
| Jacky Craycraft | Mid | ||||||||
| Ally Leipzig | Def | ||||||||
| 2013 | Jacky Craycraft - POY | Mid | Katie Colasurdo | D | Stephanie Garrett - ROY | Mid | |||
| Ana Martinez | GK | Allison Leipzig | D | ||||||
| Crystal Painter | M | Aimee Dewan | A | ||||||
| KK McCaslin | A | ||||||||
| 2012 | KK McCaslin | Attack | Aimee Dewan | Attack | |||||
| Crystal Painter | Attack | Rachel Haag | Def | ||||||
| Jacky Craycraft | Mid | ||||||||
| Megan Prickett | Mid | ||||||||
| Katie Colasurdo | Def | ||||||||
| Ana Martinez | GK | ||||||||
| 2011 | Aimee Dewan | Attack | Crystal Painter | Attack | |||||
| Christy Smith | Mid | Katie Colasurdo | Def | ||||||
| Ana Martinez | GK | ||||||||
| Jacky Craycraft | Mid | ||||||||
| Megan Prickett | Mid | ||||||||
| 2010 | Christy Smith | Mid | Haley Kern | Mid | |||||
| Jennifer Bryant | Def | Megan Prickett | Mid | ||||||
| Aimee Dewan | Attack | ||||||||
| Katie Colasurdo | Def | ||||||||
| Ana Martinez | GK |
*No All-SCIAC after season cancellation due to COVID-19
+ No First/Second team because not all SCIAC team participated in season due to COVID-19