| Category | Rank | Student-Athlete | Statistic | Year - Opponent |
| INDIVIDUAL GOALS | 1 | Greg Lackey | 5 | 1995 vs. La Verne |
| (4 goals minimum) | - | Ryan Davis | 5 | 2015 vs. Caltech |
| 3 | Adam Acosta | 4 | 2003 vs. Occiddental | |
| - | Andy Oshay | 4 | 2000 vs. La Verne | |
| - | John Hohm | 4 | 1999 vs. Caltech | |
| INDIVIDUAL POINTS | 1 | Ryan Davis | 10 | 2015 vs. Caltech |
| (6 points minimum) | - | Greg Lackey | 10 | 1995 vs. La Verne |
| 3 | Sebastian Aldaz | 9 | 2003 vs. Caltech | |
| - | Andy Oshay | 9 | 2000 vs. La Verne | |
| 5 | Ross Schunk | 8 | 2006 vs. Whittier | |
| - | Adam Acosta | 8 | 2003 vs. Whittier | |
| - | Adam Acosta | 8 | 2003 vs. Occidental | |
| - | John Hohm | 8 | 1999 vs. Caltech | |
| 9 | Charles Izydorek | 7 | 2011 vs. Caltech | |
| - | Ross Schunk | 7 | 2007 vs. Caltech | |
| - | Justin Wells | 7 | 2002 vs. Cal Lutheran | |
| 12 | Jackson Fox | 6 | 2019 vs. Caltech | |
| - | Kayvon Parsa | 6 | 2018 vs. UC Santa Cruz | |
| - | Collin ChubbFertal | 6 | 2017 vs. Caltech | |
| - | Kayvon Parsa | 6 | 2016 vs. Whittier | |
| - | Cody Carlson | 6 | 2011 vs. Whittier | |
| - | Jamie Griffin | 6 | 2010 vs. Whittier | |
| - | Cody Carlson | 6 | 2009 vs. Caltech | |
| - | Cody Carlson | 6 | 2009 vs. Caltech | |
| - | Ross Schunk | 6 | 2008 vs. Pomona-Pitzer | |
| - | Ross Schunk | 6 | 2007 vs. Occidental | |
| - | Will Roraff | 6 | 2005 vs. La Sierra | |
| - | Ross Schunk | 6 | 2005 vs. Caltech | |
| - | Bryan Fakkema | 6 | 2005 vs. Occidental | |
| - | Will Roraff | 6 | 2004 vs. Whittier | |
| - | Jacob Huber | 6 | 2004 vs. Whittier | |
| - | Jason Cloyes | 6 | 2003 vs. Caltech | |
| - | Eric Rolwing | 6 | 2003 vs. Caltech | |
| - | Sam Mirkovich | 6 | 2003 vs. Whittier | |
| - | Max Cheney | 6 | 2003 vs. Caltech | |
| - | Andy Oshay | 6 | 2000 vs. Caltech | |
| - | Riste Simnjanovski | 6 | 2000 vs. Hope International | |
| TEAM GOALS | 1 | 16 | 2003 vs. Caltech | |
| 2 | 12 | 2000 vs. Caltech | ||
| 3 | 11 | 2004 vs. Whittier | ||
| - | 11 | 2002 vs. Whittier | ||
| - | 11 | 2003 vs. Caltech | ||
| 6 | 10 | 1999 vs. Caltech | ||
| - | 10 | 2005 vs. La Sierra | ||
| 8 | 9 | 2009 vs. Caltech | ||
| - | 9 | 2001 vs. Caltech | ||
| 10 | 8 | 2012 vs. Caltech | ||
| - | 8 | 2011 vs. Caltech | ||
| - | 8 | 2008 vs. Caltech | ||
| - | 8 | 2006 vs. Caltech | ||
| - | 8 | 2005 vs. Caltech | ||
| - | 8 | 2005 vs. Caltech | ||
| - | 8 | 2005 vs. Whittier | ||
| - | 8 | 2003 vs. Whittier | ||
| - | 8 | 2001 vs. Whittier | ||
| - | 8 | 2000 vs. Caltech | ||
| TEAM ASSISTS | 1 | 18 | 2003 vs. Caltech | |
| (7 assists minimum) | 2 | 13 | 2003 vs. Whittier | |
| 3 | 12 | 2002 vs. Cal Lutheran | ||
| 4 | 9 | 2012 vs. Caltech | ||
| - | 9 | 2009 vs. Caltech | ||
| - | 9 | 2009 vs. Caltech | ||
| - | 9 | 2004 vs. Whittier | ||
| - | 9 | 1999 vs. Caltech | ||
| 9 | 8 | 2005 vs. Caltech | ||
| - | 8 | 2003 vs. Whittier | ||
| TEAM POINTS | 1 | 50 | 2002 vs. Caltech | |
| (20 points minimum) | 2 | 35 | 2003 vs. Whittier | |
| 3 | 31 | 2004 vs. Whittier | ||
| 4 | 29 | 1999 vs. Caltech | ||
| 5 | 28 | 2003 vs. Caltech | ||
| 6 | 27 | 2009 vs. Caltech | ||
| - | 27 | 2005 vs. La Sierra | ||
| - | 27 | 2001 vs. Caltech | ||
| 9 | 25 | 2012 vs. Caltech | ||
| 10 | 24 | 2005 vs. Caltech |
Updated through the 2022 season
No full 2020 season due to COVID-19.